Best island for…
Start with what you want to do. We'll name the island.
Each answer is ranked from the catalogs behind the six planners — resort attributes, beach scores, bookable tours and their reviews — not opinion.
All-Inclusive Resorts
Punta Cana
42% of 184 resorts are all-inclusive
Adults-Only Resorts
Cancún
14% of 255 resorts are adults-only
Families
Cancún
swimming 3.8/5 across 21 beaches · 40% all-inclusive · 1h 50m from the closest U.S. gateway
Honeymoons
Jamaica
12% adults-only · resorts rated 4.55 on average · restaurants 4.6
Budget Trips
Jamaica
median resort rate about $218/night
Snorkeling
Cancún
snorkeling 3.4/5 across 21 rated beaches
Scuba Diving
Cancún
76 bookable scuba diving tours · top picks rated 5.0
Fishing
Cabo
71 bookable fishing tours · top picks rated 5.0
Golf
See ranking
Which destination is best for golf?
Nightlife
Punta Cana
resort party score 2.7/5
Food & Drink
Cabo
60 bookable food & drink tours · top picks rated 4.9
Adventure
Cancún
282 bookable adventure tours · top picks rated 4.8
Boat Days
Aruba
83 bookable boat days tours · top picks rated 4.9
Whale Watching
Cabo
55 bookable whale watching tours · top picks rated 4.9
Culture & Day Trips
Cancún
210 bookable culture & day trips tours · top picks rated 4.8
Shortest Flights
Cancún
29 U.S. nonstop cities · shortest 1h 50m